FROME's Multi-Vertical Gamble: Diversification or Distraction?

Dating apps are hunting for revenue beyond subscriptions, and First Round's On Me is leading the charge in the most ambitious—and potentially reckless—way imaginable. The platform has hired Gersh Agency's brand consulting division to guide its expansion from digital matchmaking into drinks, cafés, and podcasting. Whether this represents strategic diversification or founder distraction will depend entirely on execution, and the industry is watching closely.

According to the company, Gersh will guide brand strategy across what it's calling a 'multi-vertical expansion'. That's a polite way of saying the app has decided it's also a drinks company, a hospitality operator, and a media business. The execution risk is enormous, but the diagnosis of the problem is spot on: users don't need more sophisticated algorithms, they need less friction in getting offline.

When Swipe Fatigue Meets Brand Extension

FROME built its positioning around meeting in person first, a direct response to the message-thread purgatory that's become the default experience on platforms from Hinge to Bumble. The company's logic is that if users already want to skip the app and meet for a drink, why not sell them the drink too? That's not unreasonable.

Create a free account

Unlock unlimited access and get the weekly briefing delivered to your inbox.

Register free

No spam. No password. We'll send a one-time link to confirm your email.

This is what happens when dating apps realise they're in the meetings business, not the matching business.

Dating app fatigue is well-documented, and the industry has spent years watching conversion rates from match to message to meetup deteriorate. Match Group reported in its Q3 2024 earnings that paying user growth across its portfolio had stalled. Bumble's attempts to reinvent its user experience under new CEO Lidiane Jones have been met with mixed subscriber response.

What's less clear is whether the solution is to become a lifestyle brand. FROME is making a big assumption: that its users identify strongly enough with the platform to follow it into adjacent categories. Dating apps have historically struggled with brand loyalty—people use them because they need them, not because they love them.

The Gersh hire adds a wrinkle. The agency is better known for representing actors, writers, and directors than for advising on dating app strategy. The implication is that FROME is thinking about content partnerships, influencer strategy, or possibly even entertainment IP.

Revenue Diversification or Distraction From Product-Market Fit?

Investors have spent the past two years punishing dating companies for revenue concentration. MTCH and BMBL shares are both down substantially from their peaks, in part because Wall Street sees limited paths to growth beyond wringing more revenue per user from a flat or declining base. Diversification sounds good in that context.

There's diversification, and there's doing four things badly instead of one thing well.

FROME is now operating in hospitality, consumer packaged goods, media production, and software—four industries with completely different cost structures, margin profiles, and capital requirements. Running a café in a major city means dealing with rent, staff, food safety regulations, and razor-thin margins. Launching an alcoholic beverage means navigating distribution, licensing, production minimums, and retailer relationships.

The company hasn't disclosed how much capital it's allocating to each vertical, or what success metrics look like. Without clear financials, it's impossible to know whether the café is meant to be a flagship brand experience that loses money but drives app downloads, or a standalone profit centre. The difference matters enormously.

Competitors aren't following this path. Hinge, Tinder, and Grindr have all stuck to their core platforms, layering in features like video chat, AI-assisted messaging, and safety tools. Bumble experimented with Bumble BFF and Bumble Bizz, but those remain digital-first and tightly integrated with the core app.

What Gersh's Involvement Tells Us

Hiring a talent agency's consulting arm is an odd choice for a dating app—unless the company's ambitions extend beyond matchmaking into content and media partnerships. Gersh has deep relationships with studios, streaming platforms, and production companies. If FROME is planning a reality show, a docuseries, or influencer-led content strategy, that hire makes more sense.

The podcasting vertical supports that theory. Dating content performs well across audio and video platforms, and there's a clear path to sponsorship revenue and cross-promotion. Whether FROME has the editorial capacity and audience to make that work is another question.

What's missing from the company's public narrative is clarity on how these pieces fit together. Is the café a customer acquisition channel? Is the podcast meant to drive app downloads or stand as its own revenue line? Do the drinks get served at the café, sold at retail, or both?

Match Group has spent years trying to cross-sell users across its portfolio of apps. It hasn't worked. Getting someone who uses Tinder to also try OkCupid is hard, even when both are digital products with zero switching cost. Convincing a dating app user to also buy your branded gin and listen to your podcast is a significantly higher bar.

The industry will be watching this closely, not because FROME is large enough to move the market, but because its willingness to experiment reflects the desperation and creativity the sector needs. If this works, expect copycats. If it doesn't, it'll be a case study in how not to scale a dating platform.