• HubPeople owner Michael O'Sullivan published an opinion piece on 17 November 2026 asking Apple to review how it applies App Store Guideline 4.3 to dating apps.
  • He says established dating businesses with existing customers are being rejected as 'spam' for sharing features with competitors.
  • The piece names no rejected apps and gives no rejection count, and DII has not seen an Apple response.
  • Match Group's 10-Q shows Apple's review changes have already cost it revenue this year, via the Azar removal.

HubPeople owner Michael O'Sullivan has asked Apple to review how it applies App Store Guideline 4.3, its spam rule, to dating apps. In an opinion piece published on 17 November 2026 on HubPeople's own news site, he says legitimate dating businesses with existing customers are being rejected for sharing features with competitors. Online Personals Watch relayed the piece on 18 November.

O'Sullivan says Apple can reject a dating app as spam if its profiles, matching and messaging resemble another dating app's, whatever community it is built for. He says HubPeople has experienced this firsthand. 'The fundamental problem is that, in dating, the people ARE the product,' he writes.

The DII Take

The structural point is a fair one: a similarity test written for template apps fits dating badly, because every dating app has profiles and messaging. But this is a white-label vendor lobbying in public with no named examples, and the antitrust language is unsupported until someone supplies evidence. Operators should watch whether Apple answers, not whether the argument sounds good.

Thin evidence, plain interests

O'Sullivan argues the policy may serve Apple's commercial interests and incumbents, citing its commissions and possible lower review costs. The piece offers no evidence for this. He also says that after discussions with the Online Dating and Discovery Association (ODDA), he understands other members are having similar trouble. DII has not seen an ODDA statement.

OPW publisher Mark Brooks, who says HubPeople is his client, adds that 'Apple is rejecting the new brands because they say they're too similar.' So OPW is not an independent voice here. Third-party developer guides say Apple revised 4.3 on 8 June 2026 and that the rule commonly hits white-label and multi-brand apps. DII has not checked Apple's own wording.

Apple's review changes already carry a cost

Apple removed the Azar app on 22 February 2026 after a 6 February 2026 update to the App Review Guidelines, according to Match Group (MTCH) in its 10-Q. A new version was reinstated on 6 April, and Match said the removal and required changes lowered Direct Revenue. That is not a 4.3 case. It does show how review policy translates into revenue.

Apple removed the Azar app on 22 February 2026 after a 6 February 2026 update to the App Review Guidelines, according to Match Group's 10-Q.

O'Sullivan says he would prefer a policy review to fighting individual rejections. He offers to share specific examples with anyone who has links to Apple's App Store policy or review teams. DII previously covered Apple's requirement that dating apps declare features and carry an 18+ rating.

  • HubPeople's appeal is unverified: O'Sullivan names no rejected apps, and Apple has not responded in anything DII has seen.
  • White-label and multi-brand dating platforms face the most exposure if Apple's 4.3 wording is applied as third-party guides describe.
  • Watch for named rejection cases, an ODDA position or an Apple reply.

Sources: HubPeople; Online Personals Watch; AppSubmitter; Match Group Form 10-Q (SEC); Osborne Clarke; Mondaq; Invezz